Skip to main content

Review 39: The Woman in Black by Susan Hill

The Woman in Black
Ghosts don’t exist. There’s lots of evidence we can use to support that position – where are the black and Indian ghosts in Britain? Poor people have always died in greater numbers and more tragic circumstances, why are ghosts usually of richer people? Why should the internal emotional state of someone as they die be able to externally determine whether or not they stay on and spook about? If they’re not bound by gravity, (seeing as they float about like intangible jellyfish), why do they appear on the spot on the Earth where they carked it, rather than somewhere in space, several million miles away, which is the actual geographical location that they died and from which the Earth has since tootled away? Ghosts are clearly a load of old ectoplasm.

But that said, I do really like a good ghost story, and so does pretty much everyone else. Despite their non-existence, the universality of ghost stories tells us that they’re still meaningful to people even if they’re not real, like the economy. They tell us things about ourselves, even if it’s just by the stories that strike up around them rather than actually telling us them in undulating voices backed by theremins.

That’s what drives The Woman in Black, and it’s what elevates it above a simple blood-and-wailing ghost story designed to scare. This is a ghost story concerned with injustice, and the repercussions of it.

It was written in 1984 but it reads exactly like the Victorian gothic novels it’s designed to sit alongside. Hill’s clearly spent a lot of time in this world, because it feels complete in the way that she doesn’t have to spend time describing everything – she just throws in enough detail to make the world she’s picturing crystal-clear.

Mostly set in an isolated country house, the plot revolves around a young lawyer, Arthur Kipps, who has to organise the affairs of the home’s late owner. Gradually it becomes clear that the house and the nearby village are traumatised by a malaevolent ghost, and we discover why through Kipps’ diligent paperwork and interactions with the villagers.

There’s a creeping sadness to this book that accompanies the growing tension as the ghostly occurrences multiply. Hill wrote this a few years after the death of her newborn daughter, and while I’m only speculating, it feels as though she’s ploughed the sense of grief and loss into this. There’s a depth to it that haunts the pages.

Ultimately the story is concerned with how the wrongdoings of the past can be passed down to haunt the living. Not just the culprits of the misdeeds, but the community as a whole. In a very different way, Yaa Gyasi’s Homegoing explores similar territory. Hill’s choice of writing a ghost story to do this is a brilliant idea, precisely because of the universality of ghost. We all know the metaphors of things ‘coming back to haunt us’ or being dogged by ‘the spectre’ of something we’ve done wrong. In TWIB, Hill simply extends those metaphors into an absorbing and powerful tale.

--

This is my thirty-ninth book review of 100 to raise money for Refuge, the domestic abuse charity. If you liked this review, or just want to help out, please donate on the link below!

JustGiving - Sponsor me now!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review 42: The Vegetarian by Han Kang

It’s hard not to respect trees. I try my best, but they always get me in the end, the cunning green-and-brown scamps. They don’t do anyone any harm. They just stand there, absorbing nutrients from above and below, pumping out oxygen with the quiet confidence of a wizard puffing his pipe. It would be wrong to call that the central premise of Han Kang’s The Vegetarian , because it’s not. But the idea of comparing human morality against the gentle harmlessness of vegetation rings through its core. The central character, Yeong-hye, a housewife, decides to stop eating meat. While this seems like a fairly small choice and one hardly worth building a whole novel around, the novel explores the reactions of her family and her own gradual slip into extremism in a slow-but-steady deterioration. The most intriguing, and in many ways frustrating, aspect to the novel is the impenetrability of Yeong-hye herself. You’re never quite allowed inside her head, and so have to observe her change from...

Review 19: Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine by Gail Honeyman

I imagine a lot of unimaginative reviews of this book say something like, Eleanor Oliphant is not Completely Fine, contrary to the title! and then they laugh at their own tiny joke for four hours. You won’t find that here, even though it is both true and apposite. Instead you’ll see me saying: this is a really great book. Even forgetting the inspired name of the protagonist, which never stops sounding like the name of an elegant elephant, it’s really good. Eleanor Oliphant lives alone and has forged an existence for herself of work, trips to the local Tesco Metro, and gentle, vodka-infused oblivion on the weekends. She doesn’t deal well with people. In fact, Oliphant displays an almost total lack of empathy. At first, you suspect that she may be autistic, since she shows all the signs: difficulty relating to others, low tolerance for leaving her routines, having to learn the outward signs of emotions by rote and experience, rather than innately understanding the differe...

Review 21: Whose Body?, by Dorothy L. Sayers

I like my detective stories like I like my eggs: hard-boiled. (This is a lie, I actually hate eggs, but for the purposes of a punchy opening pun, I like my eggs like I like my detective stories (hard-boiled, in case you missed it).) So it made perfect sense for me to include a few detective stories on my Quest of 100 Books (films rights available). And what better place to start than in the golden age of the detective story with one of its most celebrated female authors, Dorothy L. Sayers? Whose Body? is at one and the same time a meticulously-plotted mystery novel and also something of a pastiche of the same. It features Lord Peter Wimsey (whose name should give an indication of the novel’s tone) who has weaned himself on Sherlock Holmes stories and, with too much time and money on his hands, rather fancies himself as following poshly in his footsteps. This is to the well-wearied consternation of his butler, Bunter, who's sick of waiting up to all hours of the night wai...